School Choice and the Black Middle Class
The sad death of her son, twenty-six years old, while riding a motorcycle on a Los Angeles freeway, has brought an extended family and network of friends to our neighbor's home. For several days and evening, she has had their support and comfort, as well as advice. Naturally, as on every similar occasion in my experience, friends and family re-united, even under sorrowful circumstances, invariably turn to reminiscence of their childhood and youth together. Because our friendship with our grieving neighbor does not extend back that far, we could not contribute anecdotes; but we enjoyed listening to their stories and news. The news particularly interested me. There was much discussion of schools they attended and to which they sent or were sending their children. The schools were mostly private. In the case of one young cousin, who has elementary school children (and whom I saw nearly daily during the school year, as my walk took me by her school), she was removing them from public school. She has enrolled them in a nearby Catholic school, though she is not Catholic. I asked her about the choice. Well, it was her aunt's school, and the school of several other relatives. She made the choice, which entails considerable sacrifice, for the educational quality of the school. "My girls will learn more. They will learn discipline," she said, referring to intellectual discipline. In the crowded rooms, several other women volunteered similar information. One young woman had just graduated from a small Christian college in Texas. She said that she didn't want to leave Southern California for Texas ("It's so boring there"), but family insisted. She majored in biology and is now working as a surgical room assistant at a nearby university hospital and applying to medical school. The names of other, elementary and secondary, private schools were mentioned, but I was not familiar with them.
The choices of these families are similar to the choices of other middle class black families in our neighborhood. One family sent their two daughters to private local Christian colleges. The son went into the Navy (their father served in the Marines). This family lives in a modest home that could use some repair; but the condition of their house is clearly a sacrifice they made to pay for the high tuition of the private schools. They also have sent their daughters to Europe for month-long tours in the Summers. Last year, the oldest daughter, a teacher, travelled to New Zealand and Australia. The son sees the world with his job, of course. When they don't travel abroad, they travel to Alabama, Louisiana, Mississippi, Georgia, and other ancestral home states to visit distant cousins.
Some nearby families have opted for public schools, of course. The daughters of two of our neighbors graduated from a state college; one is in business in Las Vegas and the other is headed for teaching in public schools. The men of another neighbor's family attended Sprawling Suburb's community college. No doubt, convenience and cost were a factor in their decisions. Military service was a common route to education and vocational training for black men on our street (I can think, quickly, of three black patriarchs on our street who were military).
The decision for education and the choice often of religious schools are integral to the pattern of life-decisions of these families that has brought them success. Family life; religious life with church attendance; maintenance of networks of kith and kin; owning their homes; several I know own their own businesses; college and often private college; travel. Sacrifice of one generation for the advance of the next.
Imagine how a school voucher program could expand and strengthen the black middle class.





Recent Comments